I don't know what it is about our location, but typically the tooth fairy is late to arrive. She is always getting caught in a storm in the Midwest and often arrives 1-2 days after the tooth is lost. I've gently suggested she set an alarm on her phone for 11 p.m. next time and am hoping that does the trick (pending no storms of course). Does this happen to any of you? :)
In preparation for her next, highly-anticipated arrival, I am currently in the market for a tooth fairy pillow for my oldest son. He's recently had to borrow his sisters matryoshka tooth fairy pillow and this wasn't his favorite. I decided to take a peek at some Etsyfare and thankfully found a handful of great options after much searching; in fact, I sifted through almost one hundred pages of product! I hope these recommendations save you a good chunk of time.
tiny tooth box | tooth fairy kit | knit oeuf pillow | linen tooth fairy pillow with ticking
wooden tooth fairy box | tiny tooth box (image 2/2) | cross-stitched tooth fairy case
a couple girly options I couldn't help but slip in:
swallow tooth fairy pillow | linen tooth fairy pillow with monogram
update: for more great tooth fairy tips and stories, read Brook's post on the matter.